Related Articles

Chuck Leavell: Growing A Better America: Smart, Strong and Sustainable

"We're experiencing phenomenal growth in America, but as we go forward is that growth going to be rapid, rampant, and reckless or can it be smart, strong, and sustainable?"

Michigan man translates environmental research for public via YouTube

Dozens of leading scientists advise Sinclair, he says, and have began inviting him to join their international research and data-gathering explorations. "They know that they're challenged by communication," he says, "and they know that's a skillset that just a lot of them don't have."

Pure Michigan Focuses on Conservation, not Preservation

Celebrating its 75th anniversary, she says, the MUCC unites citizens to conserve, protect and enhance our natural resources through communication, education and advocacy. "We really want to protect peoples' rights to hunt and trap, we want to engage people," McDonough says, "and we want to help people foster a stewardship ethic."

WMEAC and Grand Valley to Recognize Outstanding Women Environmentalists

The West Michigan Environmental Action Council (WMEAC) and Grand Valley State University are presenting the second annual Women & Environment Symposium on Friday, Feb. 15 at the L.V. Eberhard Center in downtown Grand Rapids.

Impressive Local Conservancy Helps Ensure Chippewa River’s Future Well-Being

The CWC has developed an excellent interactive, web-based map of the Chippewa River, from Barryton to Midland. Also available in hard copy, the digital map provides, at the click of your mouse, clear and succinct information on a number of recreational venues along the river.

EPA Issues New Rule for Particulates in the Air


"I can remember when the air was clean and sex was dirty." - George Burns

On June 14, 2012, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced proposed regulations revising National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) under the Clean Air Act (CAA) for particulate matter (PM).  EPA will be taking public comments on the proposed rule until August 31, 2012, and has set two public hearings in Philadelphia (July 17, 2012) and Sacramento (July 19, 2012) to discuss the proposed rule.  EPA is issuing the rule in response to a court order from a lawsuit challenging earlier regulations published in 2006 during the Bush Administration, which were found not stringent enough under the CAA.  The Court required EPA to put final rules in place by December 14, 2012.


EPA describes "particulate matter"
as being "a complex mixture of extremely small particles and liquid droplets."  "Particulate pollution" is "pollution is made up of a number of components, including acids (such as nitrates and sulfates), organic chemicals, metals, and soil or dust particles."  It is measured as "fine" or "coarse" depending on the size of the diameter of the matter.  "Fine" PM is 2.5 micrometers in size or smaller, while "coarse" PM is 2.5 to 10 micrometers.


The CAA mandates that EPA regulate air quality standards to protect public health ("primary standards") and for adverse environmental effects ("secondary standards").  EPA reviews these standards every five years and either issues new regulations or leaves existing regulations in place, depending on what the science indicates is protective of primary and/or secondary standards.  For PM, the potential negative health affects relate especially to fine PM, which include "premature mortality, increased hospital admissions and emergency department visits, and development of chronic respiratory disease."  The secondary or environmental standards relate to visibility, which in some cases can be quite extreme, like in China, for example.  The complete science supporting EPA's decision, which includes 300 new epidemiological studies, can be found here (warning, it is over 2,000 pages long, with indices).


The proposed regulations lower the annual air quality standard from 15.0 micrograms per cubic meter air or  µg/m3 to 12.0 to 13.0  µg/m3, but leaves the 24-hour standard the same as the previous standard (35 µg/m3 averaged over three years).  As for secondary standards, PM would be regulated by complying with a visibility index ("deciviews").  The standards for "coarse" PM remain unchanged from the earlier version of the regulation.


If a geographic area fails to meet the standards, it is identified as a "nonattainment area" and local and state governments would then have to put into place controls that would allow the geographic area to reach "attainment" (i.e., meeting the numerical requirements) by 2020.  As NAAQS standards (whether for PM or any other regulated pollutant) become tougher, more geographic areas that were once "attainment" under earlier standards become "nonattainment," which in turn results in additional regulation at the local and state level.  States must then submit plans, called "State Implementation Plans" or "SIP" for EPA to review and approve, which demonstrates that the State can meet attainment status by 2020.


As with all rules, EPA will accept public comments, either directly or at the public hearings.  It will respond to substantive comments received before August 31, 2012, and issue a final rule by December 14, 2012.  EPA hopes that the new rules will pass judicial muster and result in billions in avoided health costs, while the cost of implementation is estimated at $2.9 million a year for meeting the 13.0 µg/m standard (upper range) and $69 million for meeting the 12.0 µg/m3 standard (lower range).  As for what ways regulators can control PM emissions, EPA has published a draft of a list of potential control mechanisms. 


The author, Saulius Mikalonis, is an environmental attorney with over 25 years of experience in the Bloomfield Hills offices of Plunkett Cooney.  He is also the author of The Green Blawg, in which he writes about environmental law issues for the non-lawyer.  In addition to practicing law, Mr. Mikalonis is an adjunct professor at the Thomas M. Cooley Law School, Auburn Hills Campus, at which he teaches a course entitled "Sustainable Development Law & Policy" and a former Board Member of the Detroit Regional Chapter of the United States Green Building Council (USGBC).
Share


Add a comment: